CU

Tug-of-War Between Bulls and Bears: Shanghai Copper Caught in a Dilemma, SunSirs Says

Copper prices have declined sharply in recent days, according to SunSirs, which attributes the drop to a combination of heightened macroeconomic risk aversion, a cooling narrative around AI-driven demand, and weakening expectations for U.S. tariffs on copper. A proposed ban on "super AI" by U.S. Democrats has rattled the global tech sector and pushed the VIX "fear index" higher.

Because medium- to long-term copper demand depends heavily on the energy transition and the construction of AI data centers, any softening in U.S. policy support for AI, combined with concerns over high financing costs and earnings pressure at AI-related firms, has led to downward revisions of AI-linked copper demand forecasts. The pricing landscape has become unusual. SunSirs notes that spot copper in China trades at a premium to both LME copper and U.S. copper, while low inventories outside the U.S. provide a floor for spot prices.

On November 6, the spot premium for copper reached 2,570 yuan per tonne, and SunSirs describes the resulting term structure as extreme, reinforcing support at the spot level. The divergence between bulls and bears has widened, as shown by a notable increase in open interest for Shanghai copper, which has reached its highest level since February this year. Meanwhile, SunSirs warns that the potential return of more than one million tonnes of inventory from the U.S. to the market has weighed on sentiment.

On the supply side, smelters are being squeezed by raw material shortages and declining profitability. Treatment charges for copper concentrate stand at -$247.35 per dry metric tonne. According to SunSirs, high spot premiums have helped offset falling by-product revenues and "inverted" raw material costs, where the cost of concentrate exceeds the value of the refined metal, slightly narrowing smelters' losses on spot concentrate purchases.

Operating rates for anode copper continue to decline and processing fees for anode plates remain low, signaling that the short-term raw material shortage persists. Citing SMM data, SunSirs reports that electrolytic copper production in October stood at 1.0867 million tonnes, down 3.0% month on month. Maintenance work across 11 smelters caused a production loss of 103,200 tonnes, a record high.

SMM projects November electrolytic copper output at 1.0821 million tonnes, suggesting a slight easing of supply-side pressure. On the demand side, high premiums are weighing on the operating rates of copper product manufacturers, and bright spots in end-use sectors are few. Last week, operating rates for refined copper rods, wires and cables, and enameled wires stood at 73.98%, 72.51%, and 76.27%, respectively.

SunSirs points to a slowing growth rate for new energy vehicles, negative growth in air conditioner production, and continued pressure on real estate investment and new construction starts, with only the power sector providing support. Investment in power grids reached 459.4 billion yuan from January to September, a 4.93% year-on-year increase and about two-thirds of the projected annual total. SunSirs expects domestic demand in November to be neutral to weak.

Internationally, the global manufacturing PMI for September came in at 53.0, remaining above the 50-point threshold for a 14th consecutive month. Inventory data point to a structural imbalance. Domestic social inventories fell by 4,400 tonnes last week to 62,500 tonnes, while bonded zone inventories dropped by 2,900 tonnes to 23,900 tonnes.

LME inventories rose by 44,700 tonnes to 319,000 tonnes, of which only about 90,000 tonnes are located outside the U.S., and COMEX inventories climbed to 733,000 tonnes. SunSirs interprets this as a further concentration of global copper stocks in the United States. A backwardated structure in the LME 0-3 month spread, combined with high domestic premiums, has pushed copper prices outside the U.S. above COMEX levels, which is likely to incentivize copper flows toward non-U.S. regions.

With the November SHFE copper contract approaching delivery and copper taking at least a month to travel from the U.S. to China, SunSirs expects the tight supply situation to persist in the near term. On the macroeconomic front, SunSirs reports that the Democratic Party has regained control of both the U.S. Senate and the House of Representatives following the midterm elections.

Market expectations have shifted quickly: expansionary fiscal policies are likely to face hurdles, and U.S.-Iran tensions may cool more rapidly, while concerns over stricter AI regulation continue to weigh on the global technology sector and risk appetite. U.S. non-farm payroll data for October exceeded expectations, pushing the probability of a 25-basis-point rate hike in December above 80% and signaling a continued hawkish stance from the Federal Reserve. The U.S.

Dollar Index remains firm with an upward bias, which is likely to cap upside potential for copper prices. In SunSirs' overall assessment, smelter production cuts remain in effect and the expected return of copper stocks from the U.S. should partly offset them, even as demand faces pressure in the short to medium term. Upward pressure on copper prices is building, but low domestic inventories are likely to limit the downside.

Caught between bullish and bearish forces, SHFE copper prices face difficulty moving decisively in either direction, and SunSirs advises a range-bound outlook, with the near-term focus on the pace at which copper stocks return from the U.S. (Source: Futures Daily, as cited by SunSirs; SMM data as cited in the SunSirs report.)

Source: sunsirs.com

Would you like to discuss this with one of our FT Specialists?

FT Mercati services can be tried free of charge for 15 days, with no obligation. Fill in the form and we will get back to you as soon as possible.